top of page

Top 10 Bagel Toppings Everyone Should Try

At Sclafani's New York Bagels & Sandwiches, we believe there is no comparison to a toasty, fresh bagel - a simple food loved at any time of day—whether for breakfast, lunch, or a quick snack. But with the help of the right toppings, this can turn into a mouthwatering treat. Should you be a fan of the classic taste of cheese spread or you want to explore new and bold flavors, the possibilities are endless. But with so many different toppings, how will you pick the right one for you? In this blog, we have rounded up 10 bagel toppings that everyone should try, as these combinations will surely bring you closer to your favorite one.


Cream Cheese Classic


A bagel filling like cream cheese is a classic that everybody loves. Add a touch of whipped cream cheese for a lighter and fluffier texture that melts in your mouth. Some coffee shops even offer a variety of flavors: chive, garlic, and even fruity flavors of strawberry and blueberries, which give you a customized experience as per your taste. When you find yourself craving something sweet, you can never go wrong with a drizzle of maple syrup and some toasted walnuts and pecans to make your own breakfast dessert. 


Smoked Salmon and Capers


You might have seen Dali-style bagels or bagels on brunch menus and how they provide a savory combination of smoked salmon and capers. Smoked or even lox salmon offers a chewy, slightly crispy texture that acts as a perfect base for the flavors of salty, briny capers. These two make a delicious combination that feels refreshing.


Avocado Smash


Looking for a nutrition-packed breakfast or brunch? A bagel topped with avocado smash is for you. The creamy freshness of avocados spreads smoothly on the bagel, and after adding seasonings of your choice, such as salt, black pepper, chili flakes, or a squeeze of fresh lemon, it becomes a flavor-packed meal. You can also add microgreens, tomatoes, or feta cheese for a Mediterranean tang.

tasty bagels

Peanut Butter and Banana


A sweet and savory combination like peanut butter and bananas is one of the most healthy and comforting fillings for bagels. Whether you're having a whole wheat bagel, honey bagel, or plain bagel, these toppings will complement all these. Peanut butter brings a creamy and nutty texture, while bananas add a touch of fruity sweetness. This topping is quick, satisfying, and perfect for breakfast or a mid-day snack.


Hummus and Veggies


For those who are fans of plant-based meals, a perfect blend of chickpeas, tahini, olive oil, and garlic, which we call hummus, along with some veggies like cucumber, bell peppers, and tomatoes on top of a whole wheat bagel, makes a perfect breakfast for you. Hummus is enriched with protein and healthy fats, while the veggies contribute fiber, vitamins, and antioxidants.


Egg and Cheese


To get the most satisfying bagel fill, which is comforting and easy to assemble, you can always go for eggs and cheese. Many sandwich shops melt the cheese until it is golden and bubbly, making it a delight for the eyes and tongue. Be it scrambled eggs, fried eggs, or poached eggs with a creamy yolk, they all go with a well-toasted bagel with a layer of bubbling mozzarella cheese. To enhance its taste, you can always add some salt, pepper, or hot sauce. This is a classic choice, and you can never go wrong with this good bagel filling.

amazing bagels

Nutella and Strawberries


A sweet and sour combination on top of a bagel toasted to crunch is like a dessert on a snowy morning that provides warmth and comfort. The creamy chocolate and the nutty flavor of hazelnut topped with sliced strawberries spread on top of your bagel add a delightful contrast of flavors. A whole wheat bagel serves as a neutral base for this topping. Some people even like to dust some powdered sugar or drizzle some honey on top of it to add extra flavor.


Tuna or Chicken Salad


This is a hearty and filling idea for topping bagels in your lunch or as a satisfying snack. Both chicken and tuna salads are made with a creamy base, which is usually Greek yogurt or mayonnaise, along with some finely chopped seasonings like celery and onions. Tuna salad goes well when you are fond of fishy flavors, but for a mild taste, you can always go for chicken salad. You can also customize the salad by adding some pickles and olives along with a drizzle of mustard or Tabasco. It is famous among many people for its flavorful and satisfying flavor and the fact that it is easy to prepare and can be used for meal prepping.


Margherita Pizza Style


A Margherita pizza-inspired bagel topping is a delicious way to bring the flavors of Italy to your breakfast or snack. It brings the nostalgic feeling right from the local streets of Italy, with the melting cheese and sauce topped with some freshly chopped basil and sliced tomatoes, bringing you a juicy and tasty tipping for your bagels. For all pizza lovers, this is a delight that can be enjoyed at any moment of the day.

bagel sandwich

Honey and Ricotta


Since ricotta cheese is soft and creamy and slightly sweet in flavor, it provides you with the perfect base for your bagels. Honey and ricotta on top of a plain or whole wheat bagel give you a sweet and creamy textured topping that can be further topped with some nutmeg, cinnamon, and some roasted, crushed nuts. This topping is light, satisfying, and perfect for people who like a quick, easy breakfast and enjoy a sweet and creamy treat that is a delight to the eyes and tastes divine.


Conclusion


So, these were the 10 amazing bagels with toppings, perfect for any time of day, satisfying your cravings whenever they strike. Whether you're in the mood for something sweet, savory, or a little bit of both, these ideas offer the best from both sides of the culinary book. Do not forget you are never confined to just one and can match the things to put in a bagel until you land on what your taste buds like. 


In case you find yourself craving a perfect bagel, we offer fresh, handmade bagels with the finest ingredients. We make sure that each bite you take is delicious. Be it grabbing breakfast, enjoying a relaxed lunch, or even hosting an event and wanting to bring something unique and unforgettable for your gathering, order now with our bagels and toppings and experience the best ones around.

Comments


bottom of page